• We The 66
  • Posts
  • 🌊 Does America Need a Caesar?

🌊 Does America Need a Caesar?

Curtis Yarvin has become one of the country’s most influential thinkers by saying it does.

Curtis Yarvin

Did someone forward you this? Subscribe here free!

By Max Frost and Barratt Dewey

Ten years ago, Curtis Yarvin was a tech guy with a blog. Today, he says America needs to get over its “dictator-phobia” and install a monarch. His vision for governance is reaching tens of millions, with ideas circulating widely at the highest levels of government, tech, and media.

Yarvin, 51, started writing about politics in 2007, publishing dense blog posts under the pen name "Mencius Moldbug” that critiqued democracy. He didn’t just challenge liberal or conservative positions – he questioned whether America should have a democracy at all. 

“It’s not even that democracy is bad; it’s just that it’s very weak. And the fact that it’s very weak is easily seen by the fact that very unpopular policies like mass immigration persist despite strong majorities being against them,” he told the New York Times this January. 

He says that the elites’ opposition to populism – their preference to rule by experts – indicates they themselves don’t like democracy. To him Congress isn’t representative – it’s an oligarchy, able to impede the will of a popularly elected executive. 

So to Yarvin, democracy isn’t inherently good: “If democracy is against the common good, it’s bad, and if it’s for the common good, it’s good.”

He calls this philosophy "neoreactionary" or "the Dark Enlightenment." At its core are several ideas: That democracy doesn't work, that government is inefficient, and that a better system of government would operate like a corporation with a CEO at the helm. The end goal, Yarvin says, would be an “American Caesar.”

"These things that we call companies are actually little monarchies,” Yarvin said in January. "If you took any of the Fortune 500 CEOs, just pick one at random and put him or her in charge of Washington. I think you'd get something much, much better than what's there.”

When recently asked if Yarvin was saying America needed to “get over its dictator-phobia,” Yarvin said, “Yes.” 

His logic was that the US has already had a dictator – several, actually, as the below section will show.

The rest of this report is for paid subscribers, who fund our journalism. If you start a two-week free trial today, you’ll be automatically entered to win a free year. Once you sign up, you can access all of our articles here!

Editor’s Note

Thanks for reading! As always, we want to hear from you: Do you agree that American democracy is “weak”? How about Yarvin’s take on dictatorship as a solution? What do you think of his growing influence in US politics? Let us know by replying to this email.

In case you’ve missed our latest stories, find them here:

And thanks to all who replied to yesterday’s report about the Army’s recent recruitment success. Below is a selection of those emails:

Noah wrote:

I’m currently working as an Army Recruiter. I think your article hits a lot of the reasons our numbers are up recently, but I’m not sure I agree that the people “willing” to serve has actually increased. The increase that we’ve seen for production has come from making more applicants eligible through the waiver process or other special programs. If someone has minor law violations, previously disqualifying medical conditions, is overweight, or can’t pass the entrance exam, we have a program or a waiver to solve that and get them in the Army. The standards used to be more strict about what conditions would disqualify you from service. The regulations around tattoos have even changed so now we can allow people with hand or neck tattoos to join when they couldn’t before. I’ve seen economic factors become the primary reason for joining the military, as opposed to the traditional values of patriotism or service. Most kids joining today have zero interest in going to war, but they do want the benefits and a paycheck every two weeks. When we look at the data on who’s joining, it’s predominantly those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds and increasingly those from minority ethnicities. The typical “good ol’ boy” from the country is joining at much lower rates. Thanks for covering this topic! Really cool to see what I do every day in one of your deep dives.

Diane wrote:

PETE HEGSETH IS "THE ONLY REASON" THE ARMY IS BOOMING.  THEY SEE SOMEONE WITH HONESTY AND INTEGRITY TRYING TO LEAD THIS COUNTRY.  I DOUBT PETE HAS 6 INCH HIGH HEELS IN HIS CLOSET AND I SERIOUSLY DOUBT HE EVER HAS PICTURES WEARING THEM.  ENOUGH SAID ON THAT SUBJECT.  PETES THE HERO NOT "TAMPON TIM".  OF COURSE WE LOVE OUR PRESIDENT TRUMP AND EVERYTHING HE DOES!!!!!

And Brayden wrote: 

I would like to add my own input on the increase in army recruitment. I read your article, and while I think the picture is almost there, there are a couple of key elements that should also be addressed. I am about to graduate from college in Biology at 22 years old so I think I can provide an interesting perspective on why people within my age range are going into the army. Without trying to sounds so dramatic, the job market as a fresh graduate is not just intimidating, it is downright difficult to find a job with 1-2 years of experience with any degree. I could not imagine what it would be like for a highschool graduate with even less or none. Most jobs are not only asking for multiple years of experience, but are also asking for some skills on top of what that experience would provide, and even if somebody does fit the criteria, it would be much easier and a much more secure placement to take those skills and use them to be an above average soldier. 

Aside from politics and how each president has handled the economy and yada yada yada, the employee search criteria is just either too complicated or asking too much out of the new employees trying to enter the market or field they have studied for. Now this could be unique from a life sciences perspective, but I can think of a good few people that are trying (and failing) to get environmental science internships or jobs that would be the dream candidate for an army recruiter because of the physical and processing demands that graduating with an environmental science degree usually takes.

Thanks, all. Have a fantastic weekend! See you tomorrow.

–Max and Max